VS2005: Developers wear many hats

I have to agree with Jeff’s blog that the seperation of the VS2005 product line into architect, developer, and tester may make sense from the point of view of MS’s development model, but a lot of shops just don’t seperate the roles in this way.

Now my current team  – XP and four of us – may not represent the target market for Team System as  we probably can’t afford it and would have to persist with open source equivalents at those prices. But MS has a right to make a profit and my concern is not the pricing, it is the bundling. Because we are small and XP we all do design, development, and testing all the time. So we need access to the suite of tools. We all use VS2003, Cruise Control, NUnit, NCover, Nant, NMock, NUnitForms, VSS (though we may switch to Subversion), Visio for UML etc. So dividing up the tool suite into different VS editions does not make sense to us. For us it would make mush more sense to see the Team System products seperately to Visual Studio, so we could get the ones we needed. By all means offer discounted bundles like Developer, Tester, and Architect, but let’s make it possible to buy the whole suite or just one or two parts. Surely MS could get more revenue from that?

I have worked for larger teams too. Even there the architect-developer mix  frequently did not exist and although a seperate test team was common, unit testing and coverage were still developer responsibilities. The roles are a product of the methodology as much as the size. In addition although I work in a small team we are part of a large enterprise, which must be the target market. Large enterprises will have small teams using Agile methods on projects. Those teams will not find their roles meshing with those identitied in the pricing.

I don’t want the bundling decisions made by sales and marketing to dictate how I organize my team. So can we rethink?





This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to VS2005: Developers wear many hats

  1. Unknown says:

    Hi Ian,I just subscribed to your blog.I also work in a small dev team (7 people), and blogged on this topic, I feel microsoft have not really improved their offering to small dev teams much over the last few years. VSS is woefully inadequate we have endured it longer than we wanted so we could see if a switch to Team System was viable. Now I think we are going to carry out futher development of our bespoke web based dev management system. Cheers,Charlie

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s